Every landlord in Maine knows the surefire way to avoid an eviction is simple: a thorough screening process. Credit checks, rental history, employment verification, retina scan — even checking to see if the applicant's car is a pigsty — you name it, we've done it! But here’s the twist: even when your background check is airtight, sh*t happens. A job loss. A medical bill. A winter oil delivery that eats up half the paycheck. Suddenly, your all-star tenant is late on rent… and they're staring down the dreaded 7-Day Notice to Quit.
As Stephen Covey put it: “Trust is the glue of life. It’s the most essential ingredient in effective communication.” In property management, that trust can be the difference between eviction and steady, long-term rental income.
Before you jump into the costly, time-consuming eviction process (lawyers, court fees, vacancy, turnover—brutal), let’s talk about five creative, Maine-specific strategies that can turn a problematic situation into a long-term win.
(Quick Disclaimer: Always follow Maine Landlord-Tenant Laws and Fair Housing Law, and consult with a qualified eviction/real estate attorney before implementing any of these strategies. This is not legal advice.)
The True Cost of Eviction in Maine
According to local landlord associations, the average eviction in Maine costs between $4,500 and $6,000 when you add up:
- Court/legal fees: $1,500+
- Sheriff/constable service: $250
- Lost rent during vacancy: $2,000–$3,000 (avg. 1–2 months)
- Turnover repairs & cleaning: $1,000+
- Advertising and leasing costs: $500+
Needless to say, an eviction hits a landlord where it hurts. Now let’s compare those numbers to five creative fixes that keep tenants in place and save landlords thousands.
1. Security Deposit Repurposing
“Give me a chance to catch up—I just need a little breathing room.” – Every late tenant, ever.
The Strategy: Let tenants apply their security deposit to back rent, then rebuild it in installments over the remainder of the lease. This has to be in writing, btw.
Case Study – Portland Triple Decker:
- Tenant is 2 months behind: $2,800 arrears
- Security deposit on file: $1,400
- Agreement: Apply $1,400 deposit now, tenant pays +$116/month over 12 months to rebuild deposit
- Landlord saves: $2,800 (arrears recovered, no vacancy loss)
- Compared to eviction: $5,000 cost avoided
Net Savings: About $4,000
Potential Risk: If the tenant breaks the lease before fully replenishing the security deposit—or worse, causes damage exceeding the funds collected—you may be left exposed.
Mitigation Strategy:
- Put the repayment terms in writing with clear language that the tenant remains liable for any damages or unpaid rent, regardless of deposit status.
- Require automatic payments (ACH or payroll deduction) to reduce default risk.
- Include a clause stating that failure to comply immediately reinstates your right to pursue a 7-Day Notice to Quit.
- Consider renter’s insurance verification to add another layer of protection.
Bottom Line: The Security Deposit Repurposing strategy works best when paired with tight documentation and consistent follow-up. It’s a short-term lifeline—not a permanent substitute for having adequate protections in place.
2. “Hire Your Tenant” (With Caution)
“If you can’t pay rent, at least add value to the property.” – A practical Maine landlord
The Strategy: Have skilled tenants perform needed maintenance or upgrades. Pay them as vendors and credit the income toward back rent.
Case Study – Biddeford Duplex:
- Tenant behind: $1,500
- Property needed trim repainted & deck repairs (contractor bid: $2,000)
- Tenant is a painter/carpenter, completes work for $1,500 credit
- Landlord saves: $500 vs hiring outside labor + keeps tenant in place
- Compared to eviction: $5,000 average cost avoided
Net Savings: About $5,500
Risk & Mitigation:
- Risk: Tenants may “hunt for projects” or intentionally damage property to create work.
- Mitigation: Use a signed scope of work, pay at market vendor rates, and require proof of skill/licensing. Treat them as a vendor with proper tax forms (1099 if needed).
(⚠️ Caution: Always document the arrangement, issue a 1099 if over IRS threshold, and make sure no Fair Housing implications. This should be a rare, case-by-case solution.)
3. Payment Frequency Pivot
“I can handle $400 a week… but $1,600 on the 1st crushes me.” – Tenant living paycheck-to-paycheck
The Strategy: Switch from monthly rent to weekly or biweekly payments to align with paychecks.
Case Study – Lewiston 4-Unit:
- Tenant behind: $1,600
- Agreement: Switch to $400/week direct ACH
- Within 4 weeks, arrears caught up
- Landlord saves: full $1,600 in arrears + tenant stabilizes going forward
- Compared to eviction: $5,000 average cost avoided
Net Savings: About $5,000
Risk & Mitigation:
- Risk: Extra admin burden tracking weekly/biweekly payments.
- Mitigation: Use ACH autopay or property management software (like Buildium, AppFolio or Rentvine) to automate collection and reminders.
4. Prepaid Utilities Swap
“Winter in Maine is brutal—my oil bill just wiped me out.” – Tenant in January
The Strategy: Temporarily roll utilities into rent at a simplified, bundled number. Tenant pays a consistent amount while catching up on arrears.
Case Study – Augusta 3-Unit:
- Tenant owes: $1,000 in rent arrears
- Landlord absorbs 2 months of $200 CMP bill + $300 oil (=$700) into rent, sets flat $1,250/month for 3 months
- Tenant avoids unpredictable spikes, catches up on arrears
- Landlord saves: $1,000 arrears + avoids vacancy loss
- Compared to eviction: $5,000 average cost avoided
Net Savings: About $4,000
Risk & Mitigation:
- Risk: Tenant may overconsume utilities since landlord is footing the bill.
- Mitigation: Cap usage in agreement (“up to $200 CMP / $300 oil”), review prior bills for baselines, and put an end date on the bundled arrangement.
5. Hardship Reset Agreement
“I just need a fresh start. Put it in writing and I’ll stick to it.” – Tenant facing eviction
The Strategy: Draft a one-page hardship agreement: tenant admits arrears, agrees to a structured repayment plan, and recommits to finishing lease.
Case Study – South Portland Condo Rental:
- Tenant behind: $2,200
- Agreement: $200/month extra over 11 months, auto-deducted
- Tenant signs acknowledgment of 7-Day Notice rights if default again
- Tenant completes plan, lease renewed the following year
- Landlord saves: $2,200 arrears + keeps unit occupied
- Compared to eviction: $5,000 average cost avoided
Net Savings: About $5,000
Risk & Mitigation:
- Risk: Tenant may sign agreement but default again.
- Mitigation: Reference Maine’s 7-Day Notice rights right in the agreement. Make payments automatic and enforce consequences immediately upon breach.
Why This Matters in Maine
Turnover in Maine is expensive. Winterizing empty units, court delays, oil deliveries, and the sheer headache of re-leasing in the middle of January can wipe out your margins. The math is clear: a $5,000 eviction vs. a $500 creative solution isn’t even a contest.
That’s where boutique property managers like HarborLight Property Management, LLC come in. We combine personal relationships with sharp strategies to keep tenants housed and landlords profitable.
The Bottom Line
Eviction is the nuclear option. Smart Maine landlords use creativity, flexibility, and structure to keep tenants in place, protect cash flow, and build long-term stability. Because here in Maine, it’s not just about rent checks—it’s about keeping roofs over heads and communities intact.
Turn the tide before you go to court. Your bottom line (and your sanity) will thank you.
Until next month,
Mike Marquis
.webp)